Margaritaville Key West vs Bahamas Comparison Review: Your Search For The Most Exciting & Customizable Margarita-Ville Blender Is Finally Over!

I get commissions for purchases made through links in this post. Read more

It takes A LOT of guesswork in a standard food blender to make a drink with ice. That’s why picking between the Margaritaville Key West vs Bahamas is a great idea. Not only are both blenders perfect for mixing cocktails at the touch of a button. But they also feature premium-grade blades that shave, not crush, ice which is 100% times better!

The Margaritaville Key West is the better opponent than the Margaritaville Bahamas for mixing cocktails at home. It has pre-programmed functions for 1-3 servings. It has a larger ice reservoir in a more portable and compact design. And the glass pitcher is sturdy and strong with dishwasher-safe parts.

The Bahamas, I would like to think, is good for beginners and solo drinkers. Though it has the same jar size as the Key West – 36 ounces – its plastic jar seems basic and has only a single button for blending.

Margaritaville Key West vs Bahamas: Comparision Chart

Image
The Winner(#1)
Margaritaville Key West Frozen Concoction Maker with Easy Pour Jar and XL Ice Reservoir
The Runner-Up(#2)
Margaritaville Bahamas Frozen Concoction Dual Mode Beverage Maker Home Margarita Machine with No-Brainer Mixer and, 36 Ounce Pitcher, Stainless Steel
Model
Margaritaville Key West
Margaritaville Bahamas
Dimensions (LxWxH)
14 x 9 x 19 Inches
16.1 x 10.7 x 22.2 Inches
Color
Green
White
Weight / Power / Voltage
19.8 Pounds / 120V
15.7 Pounds / 450W
Jar Size
36-ounce
36-ounce
Jar Material
Glass
Thick Plastic
Ice Capacity
Up To 3 Jars
1 jar
Pre-Programmed Settings
4
1
Power Rating
550
450
Drink Size of Pitcher
3
3
Self-Dispensing Function
None
None
Automatic Blending
Manual Blending
Dishwasher-Safe Parts
Easy-Pour Jar
Warranty
1 Year
1 Year
What I Like
Price
$281.99
$207.49
The Winner(#1)
Image
Margaritaville Key West Frozen Concoction Maker with Easy Pour Jar and XL Ice Reservoir
Model
Margaritaville Key West
Dimensions (LxWxH)
14 x 9 x 19 Inches
Color
Green
Weight / Power / Voltage
19.8 Pounds / 120V
Jar Size
36-ounce
Jar Material
Glass
Ice Capacity
Up To 3 Jars
Pre-Programmed Settings
4
Power Rating
550
Drink Size of Pitcher
3
Self-Dispensing Function
None
Automatic Blending
Manual Blending
Dishwasher-Safe Parts
Easy-Pour Jar
Warranty
1 Year
What I Like
Price
$281.99
More Info
The Runner-Up(#2)
Image
Margaritaville Bahamas Frozen Concoction Dual Mode Beverage Maker Home Margarita Machine with No-Brainer Mixer and, 36 Ounce Pitcher, Stainless Steel
Model
Margaritaville Bahamas
Dimensions (LxWxH)
16.1 x 10.7 x 22.2 Inches
Color
White
Weight / Power / Voltage
15.7 Pounds / 450W
Jar Size
36-ounce
Jar Material
Thick Plastic
Ice Capacity
1 jar
Pre-Programmed Settings
1
Power Rating
450
Drink Size of Pitcher
3
Self-Dispensing Function
None
Automatic Blending
Manual Blending
Dishwasher-Safe Parts
Easy-Pour Jar
Warranty
1 Year
What I Like
Price
$207.49
More Info

Last update on 2022-06-25 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Margaritaville Key West vs Bahamas: Differences

The ease with which you can make a margarita, or any other drink with ice, on the Key West is unprecedented. And for many other reasons, which I’ve stated below, the Key West wins 3 – 0 against the Bahamas.

While both the Key West and Bahamas have basic functions in common, the Key West is slightly more upgraded with pre-programmed settings and a glass pitcher.

1. Blending Performance

The Winner: Margaritaville Key West

Margaritaville Key West Blending Performance
Margaritaville Key West Blending Performance

+Motor

Possessing the same jar capacity and drink size, the Margaritaville Key West and Bahamas also feature two modes of blending: automatic and manual. But what’s different, and in favor of the Key West, is the power rating.

It’s a battle of wits if you’d like, between 550 vs 450 – with the same size and blending features. So here, power is a key feature that separates the functionalities of both blenders. And the Key West comes out at the top as being more powerful and sturdy to use for frozen drinks.

2. Controls / Settings

The Winner: Margaritaville Key West

Margaritaville Key West Settings
Margaritaville Key West Settings

+Pre-Programmed Settings

Now, for an ice blender, the Margaritaville is quite versatile and productive to use. I say this because it features 3 different drink settings in relation to the size of the drink you want to blend.

The Key West lets you pick from 1, 2, and 3 drink servings at the touch of a button. You don’t have to worry about blending the drink a bit longer or ruining the icy texture of the drink. With these pre-programmed settings, you leave the timing and speed settings to the machine itself.

On the Margarita Bahamas, you will find a single pre-programmed setting. While both blenders come with 3 drink servings capacity, in the Bahamas, you don’t have the precision in blending programmability the way you do on the Key West.

+Ice Capacity

Speaking of sizes, I would also like to point out that both the Key West and Bahamas feature a separate ice reservoir on top of the blending jar. This means you don’t need to separately add crushed ice to your cocktail after blending it.

Plus, the beauty of the Margaritaville blenders, both Key West and Bahamas, is that they shave ice, not crush ice. This creates the perfect cocktail texture, especially for a drink like margarita. The drinking experience of frozen drinks is more favorable and memorable, rather than stiff which is what crushed ice can taste like.

 But the Margaritaville Key West features a larger ice reservoir than the Bahamas. It can store up to 3 jars of ice for making 3 cocktails at once. While the Bahamas stores only 1 jar of ice at a time in its reservoir. If you’re making 3 cocktails at once, you have to refill the ice reservoir with more ice after the first drink.

Both blenders feature a 36-ounce jar for blending.

3. Cleaning & Maintenance

The Winner: Margaritaville Key West

Margaritaville Key West Maintenance
Margaritaville Key West Maintenance

+Material

The Key West is a sturdier and stronger blender for frozen drinks. This is because its jar is made up of high-quality and durable glass. And since the pitcher is made of glass, it’s heavier and very well-constructed.

There are many benefits to using glass in a blender for frozen drinks than plastic. The Bahamas features a pitcher made of thick plastic. For starters, glass is more long-lasting. It is also food-friendly and is less likely to crack than plastic even with a high blending speed.

The glass pitcher of the Key West cleans very quickly. It disassembles for rinsing and takes only a few seconds to re-assemble. You can also use another plastic pitcher on the Key West if you’d like, as it is compatible for interchangeable use.

The plastic base of the Bahamas container is prone to cracks but it is also quick and simple to clean. It’s heavy-duty with a wide base. The only benefit of using plastic instead of glass is the risk of breaking it is non-existent. With glass, you do run the risk of breaking the pitcher. Even if you drop plastic, it won’t break. But cracks are to be expected.

+Size

Despite having a smaller ice reservoir, but the same jar size as the Key West, the Bahamas has a wider and taller design. So it is bulkier to keep on the countertop than the Key West. So make sure you have plenty of room on the countertop for this beast.

Conversely, the Key West is heavier (19.8 lbs) because of its glass pitcher. The plastic pitcher on the Bahamas sheds some of the weight which is why it’s at 15.7 lbs.

But when it comes to using a frozen concoction blender, the heavier the better. So the relatively compact and heavy build of the Key West is more favorable.  

Margaritaville Key West vs Bahamas: Similarities

1. Blending Capacity

Barring the 1, 2, and 3 servings buttons on the Key West, both blenders offer the same blending size from 1 to 3 servings. They both feature the same 36-ounce jar. So you can make bar-quality drinks at home for multiple people at the same time.

This is, on its own, already an upgrade from standard one-drink blenders. The design and functionality of the Margaritaville blenders allow large quantities without making a fuss.

2. Automatic Blending

Both blenders shave the ice automatically. And the performance is such that the blades do not crush but shave the ice. This creates the more drinkable and appetizing texture of the ice which is perfect for frozen cocktails or mocktails. You can also make other drinks like an iced frappe with these blenders.

The automatic blending is quick, accurate, and more importantly, consistent. Even for blending 3 servings at a time, it won’t lose speed.

The automatic shave and blender feature on both blenders stops automatically. From the ice reservoir, the machines how much ice to add to the pitcher (with the pre-programmed features of the Key West) and when to stop blending before the ice turns to water.

This is a common complaint with standard blenders which is why buying a separate frozen blender for making cocktails is very important.

3. Dishwasher-Safe Parts

One minor inconvenience about both the Margaritaville Key West vs Bahamas is that they do not feature a self-dispensing function. This means you will need to disassemble the pitcher after use to rinse it in the kitchen sink.

But, thankfully, you can also clean the pitchers in the dishwasher.

I would like to point out that both blenders feature jars that are spill-proof thanks to the easy-pour spout. So you shouldn’t expect any mess, to begin with, for cleaning. For the quick rinse after making a drink, the jar handle makes it easy and quick to access. Plus, the dishwasher-safe parts ensure long-lasting performance and build quality.

Quick Rundown of Margaritaville Key West

Sale
Margaritaville Key West Frozen Concoction Maker with Easy Pour Jar and XL Ice Reservoir
  • Makes up to 2.5 pitchers of frozen concoctions thanks to its extra-large ice reservoir
  • Creates premium shaved ice rather than crushed ice like a blender, for an authentic frozen concoction experience. Key West Frozen Concoction Maker with 36-ounce blending jar for creating fun, tropics-inspired party drinks
  • Includes 4 pre-programmed drink settings, plus automatic shave 'n blend cycle and manual blend only/shave only cycles
  • Easy-pour Jar allows you to mix your concoction, then just pop open the hatch and pour it
  • Measures 9 x 14 x 19 inches; All parts dishwasher safe; 1-year limited warranty; Powered by 450 watts

Last update on 2022-06-25 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Pros
  • Sturdy build quality with dishwasher-safe parts.
  • Glass pitcher is thick, heavy, and easy to handle.
  • Easy-pour spout prevents spills and leaks.
  • You can make 1, 2, and 3 drinks automatically.
  • Manual blending control (toggle) is included.
  • The ice reservoir is bigger and comes with a tray for easy cleanup.
  • The blades are sharp and high-quality.
  • Cord storage at the back of the machine.
Cons
  • Some may not like glass as it breaks.

Quick Rundown of Margaritaville Bahamas

Sale
Margaritaville Bahamas Frozen Concoction Dual Mode Beverage Maker Home Margarita Machine with No-Brainer Mixer and, 36 Ounce Pitcher, Stainless Steel
  • FROZEN DRINK MAKER: Nothing captures island-inspired delight like this versatile frozen beverage maker
  • PRECISE MEASUREMENTS: No-brainer mixer is designed with markings up the side for precise measurements
  • EASY TO USE: Easy to use with automatic and manual controls that shaves and blends, blends only, or shaves only; automatic shave and blend cycle mixes the perfect amounts of ice with ingredients; manual features allow you to choose between blend or shave only
  • EASY TO POUR JAR: Features easy-pour jar for a quick, clean pour without the hassle of removing/replacing the lid
  • WHAT'S INCLUDED: Bahamas margarita machine includes 1 36-ounce pitcher and 1 no-brainer measuring cup; (L x W x H): 14 x 9 x 18 inches

Last update on 2022-06-25 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Pros
  • It can easily make 3 servings at a time.
  • Includes automatic and manual blending modes.
  • Sturdy dishwasher-safe parts with locking mechanism.
  • The thick plastic pitcher features an easy-pour spout.
  • It creates the perfect iced texture for a margarita.
Cons
  • The plastic is prone to cracking easily.
  • No pre-programmed buttons for different servings.
  • The design is too bulky.

Product Videos

Related Articles to Margaritaville Key West

  1. Margaritaville Key West vs Bali Review: Which Has Better Value For Long-Term Use? This Margaritaville Blender Can Do Better Than Most!
  2. Margaritaville Fiji vs Key West Comparison Review: Two User-Friendly & Quick Ice Blenders For Daily Use To Buy Right Now

Related Articles to Margaritaville Bahamas

  1. Margaritaville Bahamas vs Bali Review: For Perfectly Smooth & Icy Drinks Pick This Margaritaville Blender With User-Friendly Customizations

References

5/5 - (1 vote)